Collin's Coffees - Coffeehouse Hwy 58

Nestled conveniently along Highway 58 in New Lisbon, Wisconsin, Collin's Coffees - Coffeehouse Hwy 58 is much more than your average coffee stop. This charming coffee shop, bistro, café, and roaster delivers an inviting blend of expertly crafted beverages and hearty, thoughtfully prepared meals that keep locals and travelers returning time and again.

Step inside and you're immediately welcomed by a warm, friendly atmosphere — a feeling echoed in glowing reviews from visitors who speak to the genuine smiles and personal attention from the staff and owner. At Collin’s, coffee isn’t just a drink; it’s a craft. They roast their own beans, hand-selecting premium Central American coffees, which imbues every espresso, mocha, and signature iced Honey Bear Coffee with a freshness and depth rarely found elsewhere. One customer marvels at the smooth, giddy kick of a mocha made with oat milk, highlighting the beautiful balance of rich flavor and creamy texture.

The menu is a delightful mix of classic breakfast comforts and innovative bistro-style bites. Their breakfast wraps, carefully layered with Wisconsin River Meats bacon or smoked ham, cheddar cheese, eggs, and crispy hash browns, are the epitome of comfort food done exceptionally well. The standout Bacon Avocado Breakfast Wrap adds a creamy house-made guacamole, enhancing the savory, smoky bacon with a fresh, buttery twist. Each bite resonates with satisfying textures and rich Midwest flavors.

For lunch (available Friday through Sunday), the Coffeehouse Cubano Sandwich commands attention – an irresistible guest chef creation stacked with ham, chorizo, Swiss cheese, zesty pickles, mustard, and their signature roasted garlic aioli, all nestled in a crusty French roll. Alternatively, the Cheesy Chicken Fajita Wrap bursting with roasted peppers, onions, and salsa, or the BBQ Chicken Haystack Wrap layered with hash browns and vibrant BBQ sauce, showcase an inspired fusion of hearty ingredients and bold flavors.

Don’t miss their breakfast comfort offerings: flaky buttermilk biscuits are a true highlight. The Biscuits and Gravy, served with rich house-made sausage gravy, are frequently singled out for their luscious texture and comforting, nostalgic appeal. Another favorite, the Strawberry Shortcake Biscuits adorned with fresh strawberries, whipped cream, and strawberry jam, provide a perfectly sweet, fluffy indulgence to brighten any morning. The Avocado Biscuits topped with house guacamole offer a unique, fresh take that pairs brilliantly with the cozy café ambiance.

Collin’s Coffees is also attentive to today’s diverse dietary preferences—alternative milks are available, ensuring everyone can find a beverage that suits their taste. The blend of hospitality, quality ingredients, and local sourcing cultivates an experience that feels intimate yet consistently impressive.

From the genuine kindness of the owner taking time to share stories of coffee bean sourcing trips to Central America, to the freshly baked pastries to take home, Collin’s Coffees stands as a radiant example of community-centered excellence. Whether you’re fueling up for the day with a hearty breakfast wrap or catching up with a friend over one of their specialty brews, every visit to this delightful coffeehouse feels like coming home.